Essays, op-eds and letters
Alex Bäcker
Letter to the editor · May 2003
To the Editor:
The commercial impetus to get the news out first or with most impact sometimes conflicts with the accuracy of reporting the truth. We usually trust responsible media to favor the latter rather than the former. A few weeks ago, the L.A. Times showed evidence of the professional integrity of its editorial team when it admitted that a photo from the Iraq front run on the front page had, unbeknownst to the editors, been digitally altered by the photographer. Tonight, CNN’s website showed evidence that its “news” stories are sometimes prefabricated before the fact. Its story on the Soyuz landing, published at http://www.cnn.com/2003/TECH/space/05/03/soyuz.homecoming/index.html , contained a flagrant contradiction. Its first three paragraphs reported the news as it happened (the Soyuz capsule was lost for two hours after landing); while a paragraph later in the article reported that “Within minutes of landing, Russian officials took the crew to a portable medical tent”. While this represents a harmless example, the consequences of an editorial philosophy that puts speed above accuracy and adapts facts to expectations rather than stories to facts can be rather grave. I hope readers learn to tell apart media that report the facts from those that report what reporters expect to happen. Hopefully, this will in turn lead news editors to tell the difference, too.
Alex Bäcker, Ph.D.